I wrote a letter to Rick Santorum
I can't believe we're still debating this. But in response to his sneering, hyperbolic column, I felt the need to trod these well-worn paths one more time. Here's what I wrote to Rick:
Mr. Santorum:
You hit the nail on the head when you said that (civil) marriage is "a license granted by the government conferring certain governmental benefits." It's a shame that civil marriage and the religious sacrament of marriage share a name, because they really shouldn't. Civil marriage should not be subject to a religious test. For example, Catholics don't sanctify divorced people getting married again. If the majority of the population was Catholic, would it be OK to codify in law that divorced people couldn't remarry? No.
I don't support any church being required to marry anyone it doesn't want to. But I also don't support churches telling the state who they should be able to marry. That's what the separation of church and state (something I believe strengthens religion) is all about.
Best,
Adam.